The Mis-Measure of Our Discontent
The prevailing view in political science is that American conservatives and liberals intensely dislike each other and see politics as an arena for competition. But when we directly studied competitive, zero-sum thinking in politics, our results surprised us.
We set out with the goal of testing the hypothesized relation between zero-sum thinking and political animosity, setting the stage for interventions to ameliorate conflict by focusing on win-win solutions. This was meant to be a confirmatory study, but the results lead us to an expanded research project instead, recently published in Political Psychology.
To understand what we found and why it was unexpected, we need to wind the clock back to the 1970s, when political scientists started tracking Americans feelings of warmth towards members of their own and opposing political parties using a “feeling thermometer.”
On the feeling thermometer, you rate your feelings of warmth towards your own party on a scale ranging from zero (coldest) to 100 (warmest). Then, you make the same thermometer rating for the other party. The difference between the ratings is called affective polarization. The larger that number, the more affectively polarized you are.
Based on data from the American National Election Study, affective polarization has been increasing, especially since 2016, with the gap being driven by declining warmth towards the other party.
To explain this phenomenon, political scientist Shanto Iyengar and his colleagues proposed that political affiliations have become important social identities. As decades of research on Social Identity Theory shows, people derive self-esteem from social identities, motivating them to see their identity groups as especially valuable. Unfortunately, this can lead people to pursue goals that maximize the distinctiveness of their group at the expense of others.
The concern is that as we become locked in intergroup conflict, we come to believe we can only win if the other gives something up. This is called zero-sum thinking, and research has shown that it is associated with political cynicism and reluctance to engage in discourse across differences.
To test our hypothesis that zero-sum thinking would relate to affective polarization, we conducted five studies with a balanced number of conservative and liberal U.S. participants recruited from an online survey platform, with a total of 1,383 participants.
In most research, political zero-sum thinking is measured by asking participants about what happens when the other side wins. Expanding on this method, we asked participants to respond to four items where the other side wins and four items where their own side wins. By asking participants to respond to all eight items, we were able to calculate a measure of true zero-sum thinking independent of who wins.
Contrary to expectations, true zero-sum thinking was relatively rare. When we looked at the number of participants who at least somewhat agreed that politics is zero-sum no matter who wins, we found that this made up only about 11% of the total sample. A much larger percentage of participants did not believe that one side's gains come at the other side's expense, no matter who wins.
But the largest group of participants, nearly half of the total sample, reported that politics is zero-sum when their opponents win but that it is not zero-sum when their own side wins.For example, liberal participants high in zero-sum asymmetry would agree with statements including, “policies that favor conservative leaning voters come at the expense of liberal leaning voters,” but disagree with statements including, “when lawmakers leaning towards liberal policies pass bills, it often comes at the expense of conservative voters.”
We call the extent of this difference, zero-sum asymmetry, and it was strongly associated with affective polarization. At the same time, we found that it was often positively associated with civic self-efficacy, civic participation, and commitment to democratic norms. Rather than throwing out the rulebook to dominate their hated opponents, these individuals seem to double-down on democracy.
Should affective polarization be used as a measure of democratic health or be the focus of interventions? Efforts to reduce affective polarization often assume it comes from a competitive and hostile mindset. We find little evidence for this. Instead, many people seem to be upset because they see politics as asymmetrically zero-sum, as out of balance.
We are intrigued by (and currently investigating) the possibility that the positive relations of zero-sum asymmetry with civic attitudes and participation may reflect efforts to restore balance and protect democracy. Bad feelings, we suspect, might sometimes go hand-in-hand with caring about one’s community in a time of compromised reciprocity.
David Kidd is the Edmond & Lily Safra Center for Ethics' Chief Assessment Scientist, and Martino Ongis is Assistant Professor of Psychology at Franklin University Switzerland and an Edmond & Lily Safra Center Associate.